puckthefackers
Well-known member
- Joined:
- Aug 21, 2012
- Posts:
- 782
- Liked Posts:
- 868
Keeping Nagy = bigger mistake. He’s below average in every HC category.
Everyone on this list has atleast won a playoff game, and did it in under 3 full seasons as a head coach. Gase is the only exception, and even he's been to the playoffs as many times as Nagy. You really can not inarguably make the claim that Nagy, put in any of those coaches' current situations, would be any more successful than they've been this season. There really isnt "much" worse than Nagy at the HC level in the NFL. Also, "holding the group together" is a pathetic barometer to have when judging the success of a head coach, and he really hasnt even done that. They lost 6 games in a row. They beat a talent deficient, injury riddled Texans team and a mediocre Vikings team, a team they lost to a month ago, and suddenly Nagy deserves credit for "holding the group together"? What about the Titans, Colts, Rams, Packers and even the Lions making them look like clowns? How did "holding the group together" go against any team with a winning record over the past 2 months? Over the past 2 years?worst coach in the league? No one and I mean NO ONE compares to Adam Gase. But there are others much worse than Nagy too. Like the few already fired. Mike McCarthy, Adam Gase, Anthony Lynn, Doug Marrone, probably even Mike Zimmer. Point is there are MUCH worse than what we have and not sure any off season candidates could hold this group together better.
This is a solid assessment of where we’re were at and how things will likely roll out. Generally speaking, it’s actually a prudent organizational philosophy to follow. The problem I have with following it here is that I believe Nagy’s HC DNA is fundamentally flawed in two ways. First, he simply doesn’t like to run the ball (the last few weeks notwithstanding...). Second, when it comes down to the critical plays, his instinct is try and outsmart the other team, not simply out-execute them. Sort of a the-smartest-guy-on-the-field type of thing. With those flaws, I just don’t see him being a successful HC over the long haul. But I’ve resigned myself to seeing him on the sidelines for at least another year...The McCaskeys are going to be reluctant to fire anyone. They, like us, are tired of the revolving door of coaches/GMs at Halas Hall. They want stability and continuity and if they, in any way, can justify keeping them both, they will.
I meant holding the group together as a roster. Or in a morale sense. Like they believe the base of this team can win a championship and not start making drastic change. If Nagy and Pace go the team gets blown up. The culture has never been in doubt with Nagy IMO.Everyone on this list has atleast won a playoff game, and did it in under 3 full seasons as a head coach. Gase is the only exception, and even he's been to the playoffs as many times as Nagy. You really can not inarguably make the claim that Nagy, put in any of those coaches' current situations, would be any more successful than they've been this season. There really isnt "much" worse than Nagy at the HC level in the NFL. Also, "holding the group together" is a pathetic barometer to have when judging the success of a head coach, and he really hasnt even done that. They lost 6 games in a row. They beat a talent deficient, injury riddled Texans team and a mediocre Vikings team, a team they lost to a month ago, and suddenly Nagy deserves credit for "holding the group together"? What about the Titans, Colts, Rams, Packers and even the Lions making them look like clowns? How did "holding the group together" go against any team with a winning record over the past 2 months? Over the past 2 years?
worst coach in the league? No one and I mean NO ONE compares to Adam Gase. But there are others much worse than Nagy too. Like the few already fired. Mike McCarthy, Adam Gase, Anthony Lynn, Doug Marrone, probably even Mike Zimmer. Point is there are MUCH worse than what we have and not sure any off season candidates could hold this group together better.
Mike McCarthy's GB tenure was better then Payton's parallel tenure in NO, and yet McCarthy is a bad coach?
He had the number 1 O in the league this season until Dalton was his QB lol. That's a bad pairing with an awful D, the side of the ball he doesn't coach.
I don't understand how McCarthy was bad. I also don't remember why the Packers let him go. I mean he wasn't quite Holmgren level, but he was pretty close. he was within about 10 wins, if you want to use win/loss as a metric. obviously a brilliant offensive mind, 2007 Favre/Rodgers did a lot of damage on that front. yes Packer kid, I'm giving you some credit today.
Yes. If you’ve ever watched him he is a TERRIBLE coach. Terrible time management. Poor decision making. All that with a TON of coaching experience in the NFL. Hanging on Aaron Rodgers nut sack for a decade does not make him a good coach.Mike McCarthy's GB tenure was better then Payton's parallel tenure in NO, and yet McCarthy is a bad coach?
He had the number 1 O in the league this season until Dalton was his QB lol. That's a bad pairing with an awful D, the side of the ball he doesn't coach.
Yes. If you’ve ever watched him he is a TERRIBLE coach. Terrible time management. Poor decision making. All that with a TON of coaching experience in the NFL. Hanging on Aaron Rodgers nut sack for a decade does not make him a good coach.
Sad but true.The problem is that the McCasky’s are so far removed from the game that they don’t know who is legit and who is just a freaking con man. Nagy is the latter, but the McClueless’s are frozen in their paralyzed tracks that they don’t know what to do. Deer in head light ownership.
yeah but you also bought into Pizzagate so there's that...
yeah but you also bought into Pizzagate so there's that...
Please keep these in the appropriate forum. Thanks.Just got back from standing between you and full-fledged communism btw.
Rodger rodgerPlease keep these in the appropriate forum. Thanks.
I agree with Satan boy.Yes. If you’ve ever watched him he is a TERRIBLE coach. Terrible time management. Poor decision making. All that with a TON of coaching experience in the NFL. Hanging on Aaron Rodgers nut sack for a decade does not make him a good coach.
Well, I guess we see how serious the mods are about holding to their stickied rule:
Politics in the Sports Forums: New Rules
Per Zack: "This is getting out of hand. Cut the crap with politics in the sports forums. You have beliefs and Ideology for that. From here on, first offense is a warning. Second offense is a 2-day ban, then a week ban, then a longer ban. Thanks. "www.chicitysports.com
Same old CCS Cesspool.
Please note that aaronitout is admitting right here that the guy most responsible for Aaron Rodgers development (in his eyes) is long-gone from the organisation.Nonsense. None of that is true about McCarthy.
McCarthy factually had a better parallel tenure in GB then Sean Payton had in NO. The only way to call him a bad coach is to say Sean Payton is even worse.
McCarthy's completely overhauled Rodgers mechanics and developed him, whereas Paytin just kind of acquired Brees.
Your subjective declaration that McCarthy is bad at game management etc. does not overrule the fact that he is one of the most successful HCs in football, with consistent top 5/10 O his whole career.