I started watching Castle Rock. It's ok, acting is fine, plot is ok. But holy shit, some of the dialog is so bad. Every few minutes there are a few lines that are so stupid and awkward. Breaks you right out of the thing.
Thing about Stephen King, is that he is kind of a terrible writer. And not very original or clever with plot. But his genius is his characters. His books are 2/3rds character development. Almost rambling, almost irrelevant, almost mundane backstory with characters weaving in and out of each other's lives before the plot ever kicks in. He paints peoples lives and pulls the reader in until all the sudden King has populated a town with people you know. And it doesn't matter how dumb or silly the plot is or how ham fisted he is with themes or how robotic his dialog is. Cause by then you care about the characters.
Its why movies based on his stuff generally suck. The movies skip straight to the plot, the weakest part of King's stuff. Laying out a sprawling series was the perfect chance to finally get it right and build a town populated with people where you know their entire backstory from childhood. But nope. This show falls into the same trap as the movies.
The plot of all horror movies are shit.
The plot of all horror stories are shit.
Pick any horror movie out there, distill it to the plot points, and it is garbage.
Hell- boils down any movie plot to the bare bones and it becomes something a child could spit out with a crayon and 5 minutes of brainstorming.
It isnt accurate at all to point to kings plots as bad.
It isnt just the character development, it is the conflict and impending doom that he gets you to feel in the books. The weight each character carries grows page by page.
The movie translations are directorial failings. They fail to build that pressure.
The great directors bring out the feel of the books, the bad ones dont.
Comparing story lines, running man, tommyknockers, the dome, the dark tower, it, and salem's lot should have been far better than christine, stand by me, the shining, and misery.
Those last 4 stories were killer movies simply because the directors carried the tension of the characters over to the screen... no more no less.
It isnt even close to fair to jump on the plot creating ability of king.
Think of any movie you love- I guarantee there are knockoffs out there with the same plot points that suck ass because you never get invested in the characters.
It's why sequels usually suck. The plot is way more intense, but we dont care because the character is flat. No growth.