- Joined:
- May 14, 2010
- Posts:
- 17,855
- Liked Posts:
- 2,554
Yes, the entire storyline is much better in the book, but it's much different. Andrea isn't there, they don't capture glen and maggie, they already know Michone, the walker games are much better. It was a great episode, but I keep finding them taking elements from the book and then almost dumbing them down for tv. Especially the phone. Which was much better in the book. At this point I wish they'd stop trying to add anythign from the book and just go totally off script and make it it's own thing because it's constantly coming up short in the material and writing from where the book is. The experiments aren't needed... the fling with andrea wasn't needed... the almost rape scene with maggie was just awkward and not done well... It's almost like they cant' decide if they want him to be the maniac that he is or not. The show is good, but they need to shit or get off the pot.