Lol, so you think when scouts and coaches evaluate LBs those are the only things they look at? Your argument makes little sense. You and I both know that traditional stats are not the only way players are evaluated. Hell NFL teams even differ on how they record tackles. I am pretty sure John Fox and Vic Fangio will look at the tape and make an evaluation.
And I already told you my support. He graded out as the 3rd best defender on the Bears this year and by far the best LB. It's objective because the people that made that determination have no affiliation to anyone here currently discussing Briggs. Doesn't mean they are right but that is the context that the term objective is used in.
Grading out as the 3rd best defender on the worst defense in the NFL.
Remember, that defense featured:
- old guys who couldn't play any more (DJ Williams, Allen and to an extent, Jennings)
- old guys who missed a lot of time with injuries (Williams, Tillman, Ratliff)
- youngish guys who missed significant time with injuries (Conte, Houston, Young)
- blah middle of the road guys (Mundy, Bostic)
- underperforming high priced FA (Allen, Houston)
- inexperienced, poorly coached rookies (Fuller, Vereen, Sutton, Ferguson, Jones)
- Practice squad type guys and guys who probably won't be on an NFL roster next year (Hurst, Louis-Jean, Shea, Bass, Sharpton)
But hey, 35 year old oft injured out of shape Lance Briggs was the THIRD - THIRD - best guy on that team. SIGN HIM NOW!!!!!
That's what you want on the team next season?
But you are right on one thing - John Fox and Vic Fangio will evaluate him. As will Ryan Pace, who you are forgetting to mention.
Fox is a well respected long time NFL guy. Fangio is regarded as one of the best, if not the best DC in the game. Pace is the hot young upstart.
What good well respected coaches and GMs DON'T do is send out an opening day roster that features 35 year old out of shape injured LBs.
Can you point me to another respected DC, HC and GM who will trot out a 35 year old LB with injury, attitude and conditioning issues on Opening Day next year?
No. You can't. Because it's dumb.