He already has an ABOVE average QB..Why would he want to throw him away and take an AVERAGE QB
Cutler is an average QB with an elite arm.
The arm is the only elite thing about him. His mechanics are poor and revert to bad under pressure, he makes poor decisions on the field by not utilizing his checkdowns more and getting the ball to his receivers in space, he locks onto his primary receiver too much, and holds onto the ball too long.
If you think that can be mostly magically fixed in one offseason for a guy who has trusted his arm over any system his entire playing career, you have a lot more faith than I do that Cutler is coachable to THAT level, where he is able to UNLEARN his instincts he's had his whole life.
Not saying he can't do it, and the Bears fan in me would love to be wrong about him, because if he COULD do that, then I'd grant you he's above average, and potentially even elite across the board, and I'd be happy to have him. But the Bears fan in me is concerned, and rightfully so, that he ISN'T coachable to THAT level, and that whatever he learns, he will always revert to his instincts in high pressure situations instead of taking a more measured, calculated approach.