- Joined:
- Sep 15, 2012
- Posts:
- 58,849
- Liked Posts:
- 36,329
A lot of people DO HAVE evidence that PFF has inconsistent at best grades of players.
I might have the wrong game in mind, but didn't Peyton Manning have a below average score for his 7 TD performance against the Ravens?
What does that have to do with Amos specifically? It's a subjective grade which means they will be wrong sometimes just like you or I are wrong sometimes. Not sure that proves anything other than they are human.
I can look at Manning throwing for 7 TDs and be like yeah in a situation like that PFF doesn't truly reflect the performance because they grade on a play by play basis with no special bonus for throwing a TD. So those 7 TDs still can't be graded any higher than a 2. However, we obviously can take a step back and say, "Holy fuck, 7 TDs in one game" is ridiculous.
So I don't see the problem here. There will always be things that are wrong or anomalies when you are dealing with subjective grades. At the end of the year, Manning was still their top rated or top 3 rated QB that year so don't see the problem.