Broc Broc Broc Cutler has plenty of good qualities. he also has some bad
You get a gold star for actually being one of the few guys left that will still try and defend Cutler on topic HBK. I'll give you that.
That said, to address your point the problem is the bad generally out-weights the good with Cutler.
the guy will put his body on the line for the tough yards
I'll give you that, he does put it on the line, and is even sometimes borderline reckless with his body. Sometimes it works like picking up that first down trucking that Steelers DB, and other times it fucks us over like trying to make that tackle on his INT during the SD game and breaking his thumb and missing the rest of the season.
has a great arm if not one of the best in the league as far as arm str goes
True, but a strong arm isn't much good if it's not also accurate. He can throw it a mile but couldn't hit water if he fell out of a boat last year on his down the field throws. Way to many plays left out on the field unconverted.
first in last out work ethic..say what you like but it's true it's been documented throughout his career
Supposedly. We have no way to verify it but I'm willing to take it at face value. The only problem with that is if he's indeed clocking in that kind of time then why aren't we seeing it pay dividends with actual sustained improvement? That to me is worrisome.
He can be, but sadly the decision making isn't always sound as to when he should be using it and taking off for a few yards as opposed to attempting an ill advised throw into coverage.