Alex Smith was in KFC 4 years the Chiefs made the playoffs 3 of those 4 years before Mahomes with Smith making the pro bowl Probowl 2 of those 4 years and the teams record was 41-20 . Why would Nagy be thinking our situation was any way similar ?
Nagy needs to put the best offense he can on the field next year and I doubt he pushed for this guy so he can sit and play for the next guy
Fair points and plans can and will change. But I have no doubt that to start the offseason, Dalton will be the starter and it will be on Fields to prove he deserves it. He will not be handed it just on draft status at least at the beginning.
But yeah, I get what you are saying that Alex Smith was at least an incumbent and more natural to stay as the starter. I just wouldn't overlook that Dalton has played for 10 years and started over 140 games. I think that experience will give him the nod to start at least at the beginning of the season.
Nagy did show last year that he isn't afraid to make a quick change at the qb position either. So assuming that Dalton starts, he may not last long if/when he stumbles or fails to execute the offense.