I was on the "replace fields before last years draft" side.
The excuses were bullshit and the warts were undeniable and very common among qbs who fail to acclimate to the NFL.
A good qb, as in functional to decent backup quality, would have done a solid job here last year. Middle of the pack.
With the massive improvements made in this off-season so far, the expectation is very high.
If Williams is even in the ballpark of Trevor Lawrence as far as talent goes, I expect nothing less than 4000 plus yards, let's say 28 passing tds and 15 ints. That is my expectation for a top-middle teir player on a loaded team. Anything less in today's nfl would be dissapointing.
Hopefully Williams is more talented and a faster learner than Lawrence- more towards the Herbert or stroud end of the spectrum.
If he hits 4400 and 30 plus tds with less than 15 total turnovers, I would legitimately have reasonable hope that he could be a top 5 qb in the league.