The Fields cultists are really riled up after this one. There was obvious growth from Caleb showing his potential and they don't like it. They are using bad coaching and rookie mistakes in a guys 3rd start to sling mud at him. It's ridiculous and tiring.
The fact of the matter is, Fields fans don’t want Williams to do well.
They would rather say “I told you so” than see a Bears QB succeed. Sad.
If this weren’t true, they wouldn’t pull out the hyper-pedantic critiques and constant comparing until Williams’ 3rd year in the league (Fields’ put-up-or-shut-up year).
They would be able to offer fair critiques of Williams’ game without bringing up another team’s fourth year QB or comparing a rookie’s stats to a 4th year’s QB’s stats after 50 games in the league.
It would be one thing if Fields fans wanted to have actual legitimate conversations, filled with intellectually honest assertions and nuance. I’m totally fine with a Fields fan who legitimately thinks Williams isn’t as good as Fields and has the assertions to back it up to a certain extent.
But that’s not what we’re seeing. Instead, we’re seeing overly-antagonistic, sarcastic, tiring one-offs with phrases like “I’m curious” and “seriously asking,” when they are actually anything but serious.
These are not intellectual heavyweights. They’re sad, miserable people.