- Joined:
- Aug 23, 2012
- Posts:
- 9,995
- Liked Posts:
- 3,624
My favorite teams
Im sorry, its hard to respond to a book. Let me paraphrase, Watkins was not rated higher, Alcantara did not break out until that season. Baez was just in his first full year of minor league ball. Lemahieu was a major leaguer who had hit at every level and could play almost every position on the baseball field and play it well. Darwin Barney could not hit a lick.
Ian Stewart wore out his welcome in Colorado. Tulo hated him and said he was only looking out for himself. He was a selfish player that only cared about making his money. He proved with the Cubs later. Lemahieu was never given a chance and I believe would have beat out Barney in the spring. The Cubs traded him because he never developed the power people thought would happen with his large frame. Theo Epstein even said that they missed badly on that trade. So, in essence, saying a guy who is a GG and is only 26 years old has minimal value is not accurate. Ian Stewart did absolutely jack shit for the Cubs. Nothing. So, yes, no was an apporpriate response.
This sums up my feelings on the trade. And yes, it's true. Theo has said the trade was not a good one in hindsight.